AI writing tools all promise faster drafts. What separates them is how much of the draft survives your edit. Here is a 30-minute test that shows you before you pay.
Pick two jobs you really do
Choose two pieces of writing from your own week, for example a blog outline and a product description. Testing on your real work shows you more than any sample the tool offers.
Use the same brief everywhere
Write one brief with the topic, audience, tone and length, then run it through two or three tools, for example Jasper, Writesonic and Frase. Changing the brief between tools makes the results impossible to compare.
Score the drafts
- How many facts you had to correct
- How much of it sounds generic and could be about anything
- Whether it followed the tone you asked for
- How long it took to get from a blank page to something you would publish
Check every fact
AI drafts can contain confident mistakes: wrong numbers, invented quotes, features a product does not have. Verify names, figures and claims against the original source. A tool that works from a content brief gives you something to check against, but no tool removes the need to check.
Read the pricing mechanics
- Whether the plan counts words, credits or documents
- Whether the features you liked in the test are on the plan you would buy
- How many users or brand voices a plan includes
- What the price is at renewal, not only in the first term
Add your own experience before you publish
Readers and search engines both reward writing that is accurate and useful. Treat AI as a fast first draft, then add what only you know: your examples, your numbers and your opinion.
For side-by-side breakdowns, see Jasper vs Writesonic, Frase vs Writesonic and Frase vs Surfer SEO.
Some links on StackPicks are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no cost to you, and it never changes the price you pay or which tool we recommend.